Tested by experts
refrigerators
  • Best of Year 2014

Maytag MFF2558VEM Review

A stylish French door model with great overall performance.

$1,799.00
8.4 score Tested by Experts
# of refrigerators Product Score This graph shows the Maytag MFF2558VEM’s score compared to other refrigerators we tested.
Advertisement

Introduction

The Maytag MFF2558VEM (MSRP $1,799) is a stylish French door refrigerator with excellent all-around performance, though the interior doesn't feel as high-end as the exterior.

Fridge and freezer temperatures were consistent, and the vegetable drawer in this unit will keep your produce tasting fresh. Though this Maytag isn't cheap among side-by-sides and top-freezers, it's one of the least-expensive French doors we've found that still performed well in our tests. Sale prices below $1,550 make it an even better value.

Design & Usability

The Maytag MFF2558VEM has a high-end look on the outside, but the interior borrows too much from less expensive models.

Handsome right angles and horizontal-grain stainless steel distinguish the front of this Maytag. The edifice attracts fingerprints, true, but the stainless finish is easy to clean with a damp cloth.

On the whole, the interior feels a great deal cheaper than the exterior would have you believe.

Inside, the fridge will be familiar to anyone who has used a Whirlpool/Amana/Maytag fridge in the past decade. A freezer drawer rolls out from the bottom, separated into two parts by a plastic divider. Above, a more shallow drawer contains the ice maker, which unfortunately takes up about a third of that space. Up top, adjustable glass shelves with metal frames and thin plastic drawers populate the fridge. On the whole, the interior feels a great deal cheaper than the exterior would have you believe.

All controls are located on the inside of the fridge at the top. Instead of offering actual temperature readings, Maytag presents users with an ambiguous, numerical scale with a recommended setting of "4."

Advertisement

Features

The Maytag MFF2558VEM sports an easy-to-clean finish, but the crisper drawers are sticky and the shelves are quite heavy.

Like all bottom freezers, the Maytag MFF2558VEM requires some bending down to get to frozen foods. If that’s a problem, you should consider a side-by-side or top freezer. Meanwhile, shelves in the fridge are heavy and difficult to adjust because they must hook into slats at the rear of the cavity. Like most Maytag/Whirlpool/Amana fridges that we've seen, the flimsy-feeling crisper drawers stick. At least it’s easy to clean up interior spills, thanks to the plastic frames surrounding the glass shelves.

Instead of an exterior water/ice dispenser, this Maytag's freezer houses and internal ice maker and tray.

As we mentioned before, temperature controls use an arbitrary numeric scale instead of Fahrenheit/Celsius displays—if you want accurate information, you'll have to invest in your own thermometer. We do appreciate how easy it is to adjust these controls, though. Instead of an exterior water/ice dispenser, this Maytag's freezer houses an internal ice maker and tray. Some users will miss having a convenient cold water dispenser, but others will relish the clean, uninterrupted look of the exterior.

Comparable Products

Before you buy the Maytag MFF2558VEM, take a look at these other refrigerators.

Performance

With less temperature variation than many of its competitors, the Maytag MFF2558VEM boasts impressive performance.

The Maytag MFF2558VEM maintained nearly consistent temperatures throughout its fridge cavity, though the top shelves were ever so slightly cooler than the bottom ones. Food stayed at consistent temperatures without fluctuating over time, ensuring extended freshness. The same goes for the vegetable drawers: produce kept in these compartments retained plenty of moisture.

Delicious frozen goods are safe from freezer burn in this appliance.

With such a small freezer, it’s not that hard for the MFF2558VEM to keep it all uniform. Temperatures were fairly steady throughout, and any fluctuation over time was trivial. What this means for consumers is that their delicious frozen goods are safe from freezer burn in this appliance.

Additionally, if electricity sells for $0.09 per kW-h, this fridge will only cost you $32.89 a year—an excellent result for a full-sized French door model.

Conclusion

Consistent temperatures make this feature-light fridge a winner.

French door refrigerators are usually on the costly side, and the Maytag MFF2558VEM, with its MSRP of $1,799, is no exception.

This model lacks features like a water/ice dispenser or a control panel, but it is still worth the price of admission. Temperatures are consistent in both the fridge and freezer, energy usage is efficient, and the fridge interior and exterior are both easy to clean. If you can get past the small freezer compartment—a design trait shared by many French door fridges—and the flimsy vegetable drawers, the MFF2558VEM would make a welcome addition to any household in need of a refrigerator.

News and Features

Agbogbloshie flickr qampnet hero

Appliances, Not Gadgets, Make Up Majority of e-Waste

Only 7 percent of e-waste comes from cellphones and computers.

Firstbuild hackathon 22

GE Let Strangers Tear Apart Its Appliances—for Science

Slow cooker webcams? Coffee-roasting ovens? They're coming.

Kakaxi hero

A Farm-to-Table Social Network? Yep, That Exists

Kakaxi is a new social media platform connecting you to local farmers.

Coffee tips hero 2

Ask the Experts: How to Brew the Best Coffee at Home

Here's how to get the most bang from your beans.

Periscope fridgeview hero

Periscope Users Really Want to Look Inside Your Fridge

You can learn a lot about someone from their fridge.

Coke hero

Coca-Cola Tests Out a New Unified Look for Cans

Coca-Cola is set to rebrand its most iconic products worldwide.

Dacor fridge hero 2

Dacor Shows Off New, Fully Integrated Discovery Fridges

These refrigerators are fine-tuned, right down to the hinges.

Healthy diet meets dying planet

When a Healthy Diet Meets a Planet in Peril

The choices you make in the grocery aisle can change our world.

26 year old beer hero

From the Cellar: What It's Like to Drink a 26-Year-Old Beer

This beer has been sitting around since 1988. Let's drink it!